On January 1, 2010, Bennett defeated Kenny Dykstra to retain his TRP Heavyweight Championship, and retained it again against Colin Delaney on February 5, and against J.Freddie in a No Disqualification match on February 21.
The following night, they lost to The Heart Throbs (Antonio Thomas and Romeo Roselli) in a non-title match, and at the following show in May, Bennett lost to Roselli in a singles match.
On June 9, Bennett and Andrews defeated Kristian Frost and Brutus Beefcake.
Bennett formerly wrestled for Total Nonstop Action Wrestling under the ring name "The Miracle" Mike Bennett, where he became a one time TNA X Division Champion.
He has previously wrestled for the Ring of Honor (ROH) promotion, where he is a former ROH World Tag Team Champion and New Japan Pro Wrestling (NJPW), where he is a former IWGP Tag Team Champion, both held with Matt Taven.
Despite this, Bennett returned to TRP on January 5, 2007, teaming with Bryce Andrews to defeat 'Chunky But Funky' to win the TRP Tag Team Championship.